ELF Smudge Pot Cream Eyeshadow vs. MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot in Painterly

Brandefy Similarity Score:

Not very similar to the name brand.

Download the app to see the ingredient match score!

Brandefy Review

*ELF is cruelty-free but MAC is NOT* Makeup Maven, Kayla, says: MAC is $22 for 5 grams & ELF is $3 for 5.5 grams. Both products come in similar containers with a screw top lid. ELF is in plastic while MAC is in glass. Texture wise they feel similar with ELF being much more creamy. The shimmer in ELF is very subtle - no chunky glitter. Both products are very easy to blend out. I do have hooded eyes and despite this MAC did not crease while ELF did by the end of the day. I think ELF would make a great inner corner highlight or brow bone highlight versus all over the lid. While these seem similar and look similar I think MAC outperforms ELF because who wants creasing by the end of the day?

Community Reviews

Leave a review



I think elf is better. Cruelty free always #1



I’m happy to try the elf product, I have been using the Mac product for many years and it has not creased and my eye make up has lasted most of the day but if I can save $20 on make up I will try it!!!

Brandefy is reader-supported and reviews products independently. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Disclaimer: While we work to ensure that product information is correct, on occasion manufacturers may alter their ingredient lists. Actual product packaging and materials may contain more and/or different information than that shown on our Web site. We recommend that you do not solely rely on the information presented and that you always read labels, warnings, and directions before using or consuming a product. For additional information about a product, please contact the manufacturer. Content on this site is for reference purposes and is not intended to substitute for advice given by a physician, pharmacist, or other licensed health-care professional. You should not use this information as self-diagnosis or for treating a health problem or disease. Contact your health-care provider immediately if you suspect that you have a medical problem. Information and statements regarding dietary supplements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration and are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease or health condition. Brandefy assumes no liability for inaccuracies or misstatements about products.