up&up Lotion vs. Aveeno Lotion

The two differences noted in the labels are that the up&up version contains approximately 0.1% more dimethicone, and also a thickener called Magnesium Aluminium Silicate, however, our testers were unable to detect the difference in feel, look, or smell, and ranked this as a top duplicate.

The most notable difference between the two products is the packaging. The pump on the up&up version is much taller than on the Aveeno bottle, but we didn't think this difference is materially significant. Note: "Dupes" or copycats are differenct at each retailer. So far we've only tested the up&up (Target) version, so comment with any others you want us to test.

 See the bold items for the minor differences in the ingredient panel. They did not make the products visibly different. 

See the bold items for the minor differences in the ingredient panel. They did not make the products visibly different.